E. M. Forster’s 1909 novella The Machine Stops presents a chilling vision of a future where humanity depends on technology. In this dystopian world, individuals live isolated from others in underground chambers, communicating shallow ideas through screens and relying on a central “machine” to meet their every need. Though written over a century ago, the themes of The Machine Stops echo the digital dependency we face today.
This vision aligns with Sydney G. Harris‘s famous quote: “The real danger is not that computers will begin to think like men, but that men will begin to think like computers.” Harris warns that the rise of technology may lead humans to adopt a mechanised way of thinking, losing the qualities that make us human. This dehumanisation mirrors the themes of The Machine Stops, where overreliance on technology isolates people and erodes their individuality and creativity—qualities that make us human. Both authors highlight the dangers of digital dependency in diminishing our humanity.
In this blog post, I’ll explore the striking similarities between Forster’s fictional world, Harris’s cautionary words, and our modern reality.
The Rise of Digital Dependency
In The Machine Stops, the world’s inhabitants have become so reliant on technology that they no longer perform simple tasks. The “Machine” dictates every part of their lives, from communication to sustenance. Similarly, digital dependency is woven into almost every aspect of our existence today (see Figure 1). For instance, smartphones, social media, AI, and smart homes have ingrained technology in nearly every daily activity. Like the people in Forster’s world, we’ve become increasingly disconnected from reality, often choosing virtual interactions over physical ones. The convenience of screen devices has contributed to a growing sense of isolation (see Figure 2).
The Dangers of Thinking Like Machines
Moreover, Harris’ observation that humans may begin to “think like computers” speaks directly to the concerns raised in The Machine Stops. In Forster’s story, the people’s dependence on the “Machine” leads them to a routine life devoid of creativity and independent thought. They trust the Internet-like system to provide all answers (much like we do today with Google and ChatGPT!) without questioning or thinking for themselves. In our digital age, algorithms curate our content, pushing familiar ideas instead of challenging us with new ones. Social media platforms, news outlets, and search engines often reinforce existing beliefs, limiting exposure to diverse perspectives. This brainwashing, in turn, stifles our ability to think critically and independently, much like the characters in The Machine Stops, who rely on the machine for every aspect of life.
Digital Dependency Erodes Human Connection
A striking parallel between Forster’s vision and today’s reality is the erosion of human connection that comes with digital dependency. In The Machine Stops, people have little need for face-to-face interaction. Instead, they communicate through screens, relying on the machine to mediate their relationships. Today, many of us spend countless hours on digital devices, often at the expense of direct social engagement. While technology promises to connect us, it sometimes leads to disconnection as we prioritise virtual communication over meaningful in-person interactions. Thus, constant screen usage can create a sense of emotional isolation as we become more absorbed in our digital worlds.
A Call for Balance
Despite the similarities between The Machine Stops and our modern world, both Forster’s and Harris’s work reminds us that avoiding a dystopian future requires a balance between embracing technology and preserving our humanity. Harris’ warning about thinking like computers calls for us to embrace our uniquely human traits—creativity, empathy, and critical thinking. Similarly, Forster’s story is a cautionary tale about the dangers of unchecked digital dependency. We should adopt technology for its benefits, but it’s crucial not to lose sight of what makes us human. Taking time away from screens (see Figure 3), engaging in face-to-face interactions (see Figure 4), and actively seeking diverse perspectives can ensure we don’t lose our individuality to the machines we’ve created.
Key Points: The Impact of Digital Dependency on Humanity
- Forster’s Dystopia: The Machine Stops shows a future where technology leads to isolation and loss of individuality, like today’s digital dependence.
- Harris’s Warning: Sydney G. Harris warns technology may make us lose creativity and empathy, as reflected in The Machine Stops.
- Digital Dependency: Our reliance on smartphones and social media mirrors Forster’s world, causing disconnection and fewer face-to-face interactions.
- Thinking Like Machines: Algorithms limit new ideas, stifle independent thought, and reinforce existing beliefs, echoing blind trust in technology.
- Loss of Human Connection: Excessive use of digital devices erodes in-person relationships, leading to emotional isolation.
- Call for Balance: The work of Forster and Harris urges us to use technology responsibly, preserving creativity and empathy.
Conclusion: Why Digital Dependency Matters
The Machine Stops presents a chilling vision of the dangers of unchecked digital dependency. Additionally, Harris’ words echo a similar fear—that as we rely more on technology, we risk becoming like the machines we use. While the digital tools that shape our world offer incredible convenience, it’s important to remember that progress lies in using technology to enhance, not replace, human connection and critical thought. By balancing technology and humanity, we can avoid the future Forster and Harris warned about. This solution ensures we create a world where technology empowers rather than diminishes the human experience.
If you found this thought-provoking post interesting, don’t forget to like, share, and explore my other psychology-related posts.